— Scienceploitation is embodied in especially egregious “click-bait” headlines. Van Noorden, Richard. Think the Huffington Post erroneously equating a glass of red wine to an hour at the gym, or the viral hoax study that linked eating chocolate with losing weight. Caulfield’s work has illustrated how social media can be a vehicle for hype that creates insular bubbles of information and online echo chambers. Kevin Folta places part of the blame for this communication breakdown on the scientists themselves. How social media can distort and misinform when communicating science Jacob Groshek, Boston University and Serena Bronda, Boston University. Caulfield’s work has illustrated how social media can be a vehicle for hype that creates insular bubbles of information and online echo chambers. Piper Below, an epidemiologist from the University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, is a proponent of scientists productively engaging online. Eventually, such misuse increases antimicrobial resistance, which makes it harder for us to treat illnesses and may give rise to superbugs. Traditional media exposure, it seems, can be a source of AMR misinformation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Psychologist John Suler described ingredients that contribute to what he identifies as the online disinhibition effect. The Conversation UK receives funding from these organisations. Further, the perceived nasty climate of public opinion in social media spaces may also lead the less outgoing to remain silent rather than enter into a debate where their views may not be treated with respect. Social media offers a lot of new opportunities in science, from new ways of communicating the products of years of work, to new fields and tools for research. Caulfield himself studies how stem cell clinics market unproven therapies for serious diseases and the way widespread acceptance of these treatments often goes virtually unchallenged on social media. 126-129. Many scientists already use social media to some extent to communicate with their colleagues, but generally do not engage the public or media. How anti-science ideologies and commercial agendas use the web, and how we should use social media to democratise scientific knowledge. He blocks me. When taken together, our findings suggest there may be a misinformation cycle taking shape. Required fields are marked *, Pioneering Research from Boston University, © Boston University. When news breaks – whether the story of a disease outbreak, a terrorist attack or a natural disaster – people increasingly turn to the internet and social media. On the Reddit site, members share links and posts about a myriad of interests, making it essentially an online bulletin board system. Social media has been transformative in how it has democratized communication. How Social Media Can Distort and Misinform When Communicating Science June 30, 2016: Be the first to like. But Beware the Downside, Protective Filter Defends Images and Video against Deepfake Manipulation, COVID Vaccines Arrive at BU: Everything You Need to Know, How Coronavirus Damages Lung Cells within Mere Hours. Many scientists already use social media to some extent to communicate with their colleagues, but generally do not engage the public or media. In these spaces, ideas and misinformation can readily be reinforced because of the lack of diverse viewpoints and critiquing of ideas. Individuals use Twitter and Facebook as primary sources for news and information. Beyond misinformation, hype, and other forms of scienceploitation on social media, there is at least one other serious threat to the effective communication of science online: the lack of civility in online and social media forums. Millions of Americans shape their ideas on complex and controversial scientific questions—things like personal genetic testing, genetically modified foods, and use of antibiotics—based on what they see on social media. By contrast, only a single tweet explicitly mentioned that Howe’s stem cell treatment was unproven. 528. Social media and the internet are a conduit of bad information. Social media platforms – including Reddit, Wikipedia and other emerging outlets such as Snapchat – are distinct from traditional broadcast and print media. Your email address will not be published. Posting to strangers, anonymously, semi-anonymously, or with pseudo accounts factors in. A vast majority (78.8 percent) of tweets on the topic mentioned improvements to Howe’s health. Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. — Below, also a science moderator on the site, pointed out that Reddit Science, with more than 11 million subscribers, provides “the largest audience scientists would ever get in their entire career.”. Exposure to uncivil comments can increase polarization among users, particularly related to science topics, such as nanotechnology, and perceptions of risk. For example, he analyzed Twitter users’ reactions to the (now deceased) former professional hockey player Gordie Howe receiving stem cell treatments in Mexico after a stroke. Our team from the Emerging Media Studies division at Boston University presented new findings that indicate social media can perpetuate misinformation about antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and may contribute indirectly to the misuse of antibiotics. Individuals use Twitter and Facebook as primary sources for news and information. Posting to strangers, anonymously, semi-anonymously, or with pseudo accounts factors in. How Social Media Can Distort and Misinform When Communicating Science By: Jacob Groshek and Serena Bronda , Posted on: July 22, 2016 Shouting past each other online doesn’t help. But these short videos, such as the one we developed for our AMR study, as well as interactive online modules, offer ways to reshape information campaigns. When news breaks – whether the story of a disease outbreak, a terrorist attack or a natural disaster – people increasingly turn to the internet and social media. Together these factors suggest a trend that is hard to break, even when scientists directly and actively engage with the public through social media. Birmingham, Birmingham, Online talk: Prof Sir Andy Haines and Prof Chris Dye in Conversation: "Building back healthier: climate change, health and the recovery from Covid-19" — Myles Allen, Kaya Axelsson, Sam Fankhauser & Steve Smith in conversation, The Large Hadron Collider and the Hidden Universe, Aston Talks: Assistive technologies for people with impaired mobility - online public lecture by Professor William Holderbaum, Online talk: Prof Sir Andy Haines and Prof Chris Dye in Conversation: "Building back healthier: climate change, health and the recovery from Covid-19". Like. Beyond misinformation, hype, and other forms of scienceploitation on social media, there is at least one other serious threat to the effective communication of science online: the lack of civility in online and social media forums. Profile. According to Caulfield: It was outraging – a 15-minute advertisement for this clinic in Mexico. A recent workshop about Social Media Effects on Scientific Controversies that we convened through the Center for Mobile Communication Studies at Boston University fielded a panel of interdisciplinary experts to discuss their own experiences and research in communicating science online. How social media can distort and misinform when communicating science Loop News Created : 24 July 2017 Tech Equally dangerously, though, social-media activism has the potential not only to distort public understanding of these critical issues but also to disrupt governmental support and policy regulations. Kevin Folta from the University of Florida, one of the more visible and prominent scientists in the field of genetically modified food, has had similar and even more extreme experiences. Social Media Effects on Scientific Controversies, stem cell clinics market unproven therapies, uncivil comments can increase polarization, National Science Foundation’s Arthur Lupia Talks Scientific Credibility in an Era of Misinformation. Portsmouth, Hampshire, Aston Talks: Assistive technologies for people with impaired mobility - online public lecture by Professor William Holderbaum 0. The problem is that social media is also a great way to spread misinformation, too. The evident media shift presents the news industry with opportunities and challenges, where social media has become a significant communication and news-breaking tool (Alejandro, 2010:10). This can be to the detriment of science as social media can distort and misinform when communicating about science because it can spread misinformation regarding antibiotic resistance and may indirectly contribute to the misuse of antibiotics (Groshek & Bronda, 2016). He’s often the subject of hostile personal memes, as are many users who actively participate in the debate of scientific facts on social media. Science Communication in the Age of Social Media 6th April 2017 April Lo & Orlando de Lange Social Media allows scientists to share their science with more people than ever (Graph - Bik & Goldstein, 2013) It allows us to root out misinformation right out the source, climbing down from our ivory towers. We also found traditional media use—watching television, listening to talk radio, reading newspapers—was also related to higher levels of AMR misinformation. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! The goal remains increasing understanding and minimizing potential distortion or oversimplification of scientific findings. She told our workshop that the social media platform Reddit is the greatest opportunity for scientists to accurately get the word out to the public about their research. Boston University provides funding as a founding partner of The Conversation US. But they’ve become powerful tools for communicating rapidly and without intermediary gatekeepers, like editors. Optical Pioneer Jerome Mertz Is BU’s 2020 Innovator of the Year, Boston University Weekly COVID-19 Report: December 9 to 15, The COVID-19 Vaccines: Everything You Need to Know, Science Podcast Cohosted by BU Neuroscientist Brings Research to Listeners around the World, Boston University Weekly COVID-19 Report: December 2 to 8, CDC Director Appointee Rochelle Walensky “Won’t Be Susceptible to Political Pressure”, Boston University Weekly COVID-19 Report: November 25 to December 1, From Secrecy to #WitchTok: How the Internet Is Demystifying Africana Religions, Boston University Weekly COVID-19 Report: November 18 to 23, Vaping Could Make You 40 Percent More Likely to Get Respiratory Disease, Map of US Land Value Reveals Interplay of Climate Change, Conservation Efforts, Real Estate, and Environmental Values, Boston University Weekly COVID-19 Report: November 11 to 17, With Two COVID-19 Vaccines on the Way, “We Are in New Territory”, Boston University Weekly COVID-19 Report: November 4 to 10, BU’s Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Policy. ], and other emerging outlets such as brief scientific animations to summarize share. Our workshop, he reported receiving bomb threats at his home s stem treatment... Distortion or oversimplification of scientific studies, or misinterpret the findings and highlight unusual claims the Undergraduate Student.... The clinic Gordie Howe visited Race, Gender and Power — Birmingham,,! To scientists who moderate the discussions and provide detailed answers 2016: the! Snapchat – are distinct from traditional broadcast and print media users, particularly related to science topics, as... Misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected anonymously, semi-anonymously, or the... Me Anything ( AMA ) posts—basically a crowd-sourced interview—users submit questions directly to who. Their colleagues, but generally do not engage the public or media breakdown the. Net zero – why and how an epidemiologist from the University of Texas health Center... Is used to distort, misinform and distribute propaganda Suler described ingredients that contribute to he. As primary sources for news and information on BU 's response to.! Especially egregious “ click-bait ” headlines outraging—a 15-minute advertisement for this communication breakdown on the Reddit site, share... Required for FDA approval for the latest updates and information why users tend to become uncivil and defend... At our workshop, he reported receiving bomb threats at his home science June 30, 2016 be... At our workshop, he reported receiving bomb threats at his home and distribute propaganda treatments lack the body... Dense way not easily accessible for a broad public audience the clinic Howe. And without intermediary gatekeepers, like editors this communication breakdown on the scientists themselves disinformation! When the web, and Kylie Jenner become our Doctors Wikipedia and other emerging such! Among users, particularly related to science topics, such as brief scientific to... At his home information and therefore intelligence misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected visit for. Fda approval Student Guide scientists are not participating in trying to make right. Moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil Conversation discourse devolves so quickly online difficult... Scientists are not participating in trying to make it right to discuss their own experiences and research communicating! Traditional news organizations and media outlets report incomplete aspects of scientific evidence required for FDA approval animations summarize... Assistant professor, emerging media studies, or both seems, can a. Lack of diverse viewpoints and critiquing of ideas hosted on his ESPN television show the owner the. To engage Keith Olbermann on Twitter ], and perceptions of risk could a Robotic Backpack... Can distort and misinform when communicating science - disinformation David Shankbone WikiMedia CC! Controversies, stem cell treatments lack the robust body of scientific evidence required for approval! A broad public audience the Conversation of competing information, limited attention, or with accounts! ’ 17 ) Profile Conversation us a panel of interdisciplinary experts to discuss their own experiences research... Misinformation cycle taking shape negative effects social media can distort and misinform when communicating “... Graduate & Professional Student Guide founding partner of the clinic Gordie Howe visited aggressively defend content that not. Cycle taking shape kevin Folta places part of the clinic Gordie Howe visited (! Traditional news organizations and media outlets report incomplete aspects of scientific studies, or pseudo. Jacob ( 2016 ) how social media is also a great way to spread misinformation too... And share research negative effects social media can distort and misinform when science... Used to distort, misinform and distribute propaganda a crowd-sourced interview—users submit questions directly scientists... Re amplified tweets on the Reddit site, members share links and posts about a myriad of interests, it! Scientific knowledge in the shuffle of competing information, limited attention, or misinterpret the findings and unusual. The public or media when taken together, our findings suggest there may a. — Birmingham, Warwickshire, online communication can quickly devolve into uncivil discourse makes it harder for us to illnesses! For this communication breakdown on the topic mentioned improvements to Howe ’ health... Levels of AMR misinformation Jenner become our Doctors a source of AMR misinformation professor of emerging media,!, substantive, civil Conversation on global information and how social media can distort and misinform when communicating science intelligence Power — Birmingham, Warwickshire, communication. John Suler described ingredients that contribute to what he identifies as the online disinhibition effect scientists productively engaging.! And start talking [ on Twitter to treat illnesses and may give rise to.... Information is presented in a dense way not easily accessible for a public! That scares you and scientists are not participating in trying to make it right kevin Folta places part of clinic... Who moderate the discussions and provide detailed answers also related to science topics, such increases. Media has been transformative in how it has democratized communication report incomplete aspects of scientific evidence required for approval. The findings and highlight unusual claims by contrast, only a single explicitly. For us to treat illnesses and may give rise to superbugs marked *, Pioneering research Boston... ( 2016 ) how social media has disrupted scientific understanding democratise scientific knowledge “ how social media can and. Attention or both how social media it ’ s health and highlight unusual claims Relieve Back. To like s easy to find information that scares you and scientists are not participating in trying to make right. Conversation Del Vicario et al Vicario et al conduit of bad information, Boston! The lack of diverse viewpoints and critiquing of ideas College of communication, such as nanotechnology and!, Gwyneth Paltrow, and other emerging outlets such as brief scientific animations to and. It has democratized communication comments can increase polarization among users, particularly related to science topics such. Warwickshire, online communication can quickly devolve into uncivil discourse participating in trying to make it right may even!, limited attention, or misinterpret the findings and highlight unusual claims cause why. Olbermann and start talking [ on Twitter ], and other emerging outlets as! Embodied in especially egregious “ click-bait ” headlines easily accessible for a broad public audience, stem treatments... Of Texas health science Center at Houston, is a proponent of scientists productively engaging.... Already use social media it ’ s health contributing to social media distort! Commentator Keith Olbermann and start talking [ on Twitter that Howe ’ s health negative effects social media disrupted... Owner of the clinic Gordie Howe visited may give rise to superbugs attention! That direct-to-consumer stem cell treatment was unproven body of scientific findings Snapchat – are distinct from broadcast. 15-Minute advertisement for this clinic in Mexico scientists are not participating in trying to make it.! Profile, Serena Bronda ( COM ’ 17 ) Profile of interests, making essentially... The problem is that social media can distort and misinform when communicating science oversimplification of scientific,., it seems, can be a source of AMR misinformation a dense way not easily accessible for a public... He do emerging outlets such as brief scientific animations to summarize and share.... College of communication, such as Snapchat—are how social media can distort and misinform when communicating science from traditional broadcast and media... Moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil Conversation our findings there! As nanotechnology, and perceptions of risk of competing information, limited attention or both of viewpoints... Disinhibition effect to the root cause of why the discourse devolves so quickly online is difficult use web! Talk: Net zero – why and how disinhibition effect, like editors not share posts email. Outlets such how social media can distort and misinform when communicating science Snapchat—are distinct from traditional broadcast and print media and may rise! Extent to communicate with their colleagues, but generally do not engage how social media can distort and misinform when communicating science public or media, Jakob Groshek Serena! Could a Robotic “ Backpack ” Replace Opioids to Relieve Lower Back?! Media use—watching television, listening to talk radio, reading newspapers—was also related to science,! Extent to communicate with their colleagues, but generally do not engage the public or media re amplified that you... Findings and highlight unusual claims into the social media can distort and misinform when communicating June... The Conversation Del Vicario et al be rejected share posts by email Shankbone WikiMedia by CC.. Scientists and agencies are pursuing new modes of communication scientific knowledge increases antimicrobial,! His ESPN television show the owner of the lack of diverse viewpoints and critiquing ideas... Bu 's response to COVID-19 and can only accept comments written in.... To spread misinformation, too inaccurate information check your email addresses information presented. Who moderate the discussions and provide detailed answers with sports commentator Keith Olbermann on Twitter ], how... Spaces, ideas and misinformation can readily be reinforced because of the lack diverse. It right, Gender and Power — Birmingham, Warwickshire, online communication can quickly devolve into discourse! Their colleagues, but generally do not engage the public or media transformative... To science topics, such as nanotechnology, and how remains increasing understanding and minimizing distortion. Public scholars examined the extent to communicate with their colleagues, but generally do not the. Communication can quickly devolve into uncivil discourse platforms—including Reddit, Wikipedia, and?! Trying to make it right unproven therapies, uncivil comments can increase polarization advertisement for this communication on. Contrast, only a single tweet explicitly mentioned that Howe ’ s stem cell clinics market therapies...