Id love to own a good J45 for solo type stuff tho, or for an acoustic in a country band. Messages 2,547. The J-45 also features a rosewood finger board that is inspected carefully by experts and paired by real mother of pearl dot inlays. I guess I am always looking for something different/better...whatever. While it may seem like comparing apples to oranges, one can’t help but wonder which wonder guitar outshines the other. Both here. When i was young the best guitar sound id ever heard from a git that i personally played was from a Guild 12 string from 1980. While the difference between these two brands of guitar is more than 1000$ . Hands down Gibson wins in my opinion. I have liked some of the J45's I have played and others have sounded like a $200 epiphone. © PrimelyTech, Inc., a Delaware-registered company. The excellent tone woods of the D-28 greatly contributes to the guitar’s well-balanced tone with a slight touch of sweetness. Featuring a nitrocellulose finish, the Gibson J-45 gives off a sound from with less interference with the natural vibration of the guitar, producing a purer overall tone. Messages 145. Very different guitars with different builds and feels. The Gibson can cover all types of music. With its scalloped, radiused top bracing, the J-45 gives a natural acoustic sound that is more focused toward the center of the body, giving it good sound projection. On paper, it seems like Martin's D-18 and Gibson's J-45/J-50 (let's not forget that the J-50 is the same guitar with natural finish) should be directly comparable, and in the "old days" of the 40s, 50s and 60s they certainly competed head to head in the marketplace, but they were and are quite different. The Hummingbird is also a great country guitar. BigD Friend of Leo's. Source(s): https://shrinks.im/a0iy5. (in the market for a Martin to add to the family) The D18s pack a lot of punch, have a lot of cut and have that powerful, classic sound. New Martin D18 or Gibson J45? This is easy: Gibson J45 Standard Sunburst: 2599 euros Martin D18: 2649 euros There's a 50 euro difference between the two and a pre-installed LR Baggs pick up in the Gibson. I have had a Yamaha FG730S since 2003. Bien que de conception similaire, les différences de tonalités s Members; C70man 3 Posted November 16, 2009. I owned a HD-28 (very similar to D-28, also a D-35) and have had three versions of the J-45 (Standard, Custom, TV). If you have been playing the guitar for a long time, I’m sure there hasn’t been a time where you wonder if you could ever play such awesome and legendary guitars. But, what if you are to choose between two legendary classics from both well-known brands? If you are to pick which Taylor guitars are sounds like a dream and are excellently made, the Taylor 814CE and 614CE are good... Gibson J-45 Standard Acoustic-Electric Guitar, Vintage Sunburst. 0 0. Gibson J45 ou Martin D15. 1 of 3 Go to page. I own the Gibson J45 and the D28, you're not gonna want to hear it, but it really is apples and oranges. Quick Answer While some may prefer the tried and tested classic Martin D-28, we think that Martin D-18 is the better acoustic guitar. Seriously. And as time passes, its sound quality will only get better. the J-45 is a lighter guitar, I love the slope shoulders. Visit us at www.guitargallery.co.za for more information. One of its eye-catching detail is the pick guard that’s made of standard plain tortoise in a tear drop shape, which has been there since its original design in 1942. Aug 22, 2018 #1 Hey guys, I've owned a Martin D-28 for about 18 years now and it sounds amazing. Baggs Element Active Acoustic Pickup System and an onboard preamp, the J-45 has an improved, robust and lively acoustic sound. Just a thought, Hey there Jimmy, thanks for the suggestion. I suppose mine isn't a fair comparison, as the Martin is Rosewood, and the Gibson is Mahogany, but I like them both. Tried and tested through time, the Martin D-28 has blessed numerous famous artists like Bob Dylan, Johnny Cash, Elvis Presley, and a lot more. Se vi siete appassionati alla chitarra acustica, in particolare modo agli strumenti più high end, avrete sicuramente preso in considerazione almeno una volta due icone del mondo acustico made in USA: Martin D28 e Gibson J45. Share. Joe M. 299 14. Its boomy and rich sound makes it perfect for every bluegrass or country music. Guitar Gallery compares the Martin D-18 and the Gibson J-45 True Vintage. My description would be this. Message par joa » sam. Built to last for a lifetime, the D-28 has all of its parts made from only the highest quality with excellent craftsmanship. Modérateurs : Benoit de Bretagne, chloé, carlos. The Slums of Newport News; Report post; Posted May 6, 2020 (edited) I owned both at the same time for about 9 … Left-T. Lv 7. La Martin D28 e la Gibson J45 hanno scritto pagine indelebili della musica folk. It is a really good guitar and I like it. I currently own a a 2011 Martin D-28. You can be the judge....nice … Reactions: Edmond and Burwabit. I have three lovely GE/Marquis-series Martins that I love dearly. Problem is, I've got really small hands and have developed arthritis, so I was wondering if a Gibson J-45 might be easier for me to play. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; Prev; 1; 2; Next; Page 2 of 2 . Great guitars. Anybody … The Unofficial Martin Guitar Forum. I feel like a D-28 is meant to be big and bold (think Bluegrass). You have entered an incorrect email address! Recommended Posts. The Gibson can and does produce both sounds! The 28s have the rosewood overtones but I like the 35s better. , To my ear the J-45 is a finer, more complex wine…. En mettant de coté ce que cette question peut avoir de débile car les gouts et les couleurs ainsi que les modeles ne sont peut être pas dans la même cour faites moi part de vos avis Merci. Taylor 814CE vs Taylor 614CE – Which is The Better Guitar? Gibson J45 vs Martin HD28 Gibson J45 vs Martin HD28. However, the D-28 is more than what meets the eye with its Sitka spruce top and solid Indian rosewood back and sides. Ne raccontiamo la storia e analizziamo le differenze sul campo. DISCUSSIONS. Martin D-18 vs Martin D-28 – Which is The Better Guitar? Taylor 914ce vs Taylor 814ce – Which is The Better Guitar? Go. Taylor 714ce vs Taylor 814ce – Which is The Better Guitar? Martin D-28 vs. Gibson J-45 for small hands. An Unofficial forum for those who love Martin instruments - Founded by Steve Stallings. Post 10:10 PM - Apr 29 #1 2020-04-29T22:10. It features an X bracing design allowing it to own a punchy, deep lows with warm mids, and crisp highs. Oct 22, 2013 #9. gibson J-45 vs martin D-28. Location: Northeast Ohio, USA, Planet Earth. By Joe M, April 29, 2020 in Gibson Acoustic. Handcrafted around the sound hole is the simple single-ring rosette featuring three-ply binding to complete the elegant look of the Gibson J-45. We’ll look into it and compare these 2 guitars soon! Finally decided to take the plunge and buy myself a decent acoustic guitar: I have narrowed the choice down to a Gibson J45 or a Martin D28 but can't really decide which one to buy. The J-45 gets played a great deal more than the HD-28V. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; Prev; 1; 2; 3; Next; Page 1 of 3 . Shouldn’t you have compared the J45 to the D35? I own and HD28 and a D35, but the D35 has the lower sounds of the J45. Gibson J45 Vintage vs Martin HD28. Registered Member. 766 20. Jan 16, 2014 #1 Getting a new acoustic in the next few weeks. The Martin is perfect for say bluegrass! I own the two guitars in the title and am kinda stumped about the sound of each. NOTIFICATIONS. Equipped with L.R. The Martin has, as some here have stated, the boom overtones and to me not as balanced across all the strings as the Mahogany J-45 is. It is a copy of a D28 I believe. The J45 seems a little more mellow, has that Gibson 'thunk' and sounds a bit more singer-songwriter/folkish to me. Thanks for all the great input. - "better" sound is subjective to the individual. Martin D-18 vs Gibson J-45. We may earn commission from purchases made through links found on our site. EIN 37-1912117. I had my 1999 HD-28V about 7 years before I purchased my 2007 J-45TV. MESSAGES. Since then (for acoustics) i owned martin d12, martin d16rgt, martin omcpa4, several epiphones, yamahas, ibanez and now a gibson j15. With the D-28’s strong and clear tone, it’s the perfect companion for any gig or performance of a lifetime. août 08, 2009 9:01 am. Related: Martin D-18 VS Gibson J-45. One of the main reasons I prefer (much prefer) the D28 over the HD28 is the "thump" / less overtones / and slight faster decay on the sustain the D28 has compared to the HD28. Joined: Feb 20, 2009 Location: Arkansas. I also plan to use it to play slide. It felt like a good pair of jeans: comfortable and easy to kick back in. First introduced in 1942, Gibson’s top-selling acoustic guitar, Gibson J-45, has made its mark on the music industry. Both guitars are known to be big models and have great reputation from each brands. Thread starter deadletteroffice; Start date Jan 16, 2014; 1; 2; Next. My Hummingbird, while having a different personality from the J-45, fits the same niche for me. With its neck having a satin finish and select hardwood material, you’ll be getting a great playability. Not really looking for the old "apples to oranges" arguments. Here are the detailed specs of each guitar: AXE HEAVEN J-45 Acoustic Guitar 1:4 Scale Mini Guitar Model, Buddy Holly Gold Gibson J-45 Acoustic Guitar Sacramento California Hard Rock Cafe, J. Rockett Audio Designs Tour Series .45 Caliber Overdrive Guitar Effects Pedal, Gibson 16 pc Decorated Ceramic Handled Stainless Steel Flatware, Set, Service for 4, AXE HEAVEN Slash Guitar J-45 Vermillion Burst Acoustic 1:4 Scale Mini Guitar Model, Martin Guitar Standard Series Acoustic Guitars, Hand-Built Martin Guitars with Authentic Wood D-28, Martin Guitar Standard Series Acoustic Guitars, Hand-Built Martin Guitars with Authentic Wood, Martin Guitar Standard Series Acoustic Guitars, Hand-Built Martin Guitars with Authentic Wood D-41, Gibson J-45 Standard Acoustic-Electric Guitar, Martin Standard Series D-28 Dreadnought Acoustic Guitar Natural. Share Followers 0. With each of these guitars having distinct features and construction, both have their own strengths and weaknesses. For an all-around guitar, the J45 or the Martin D28 are your best choice. Let’s not forget the pleasing and attractive look of the famous J-45. Body Body type: D-14 Fret Cutaway: Non-cutaway Top wood: Sitka Spruce Back & sides: East Indian rosewood Bracing pattern: Non scalloped X-type Body finish: Gloss Orientation: Right handed Neck Neck shape: Low profile Standard Taper Nut width: 1.69" (43mm) Fingerboard: Ebony Neck wood: Select Hardwood Scale length: 25.4" Number of frets: 20 Neck finish: Satin Electronics Pic, The tone of the Martin D-28 Acoustic Guitar is what separates it from all other guitars, For a dreadnought that is considered as iconic and historic, it has a reasonable price, Its design makes it easy to use, especially to small-handed guitar players, Comfortable neck makes fingerstyle and strumming relatively easy, Attractive design and high quality accessories, For a guitar that is compact, it seems to be relatively lightweight. Guitar Junky is an music-oriented digital magazine that aims to provide the best reviews and guides on musical instruments. Complete with great playability, there are no dull moments with the D-28. Next Last. A different sound than a Martin, but still great. I'd think of the D-28 as a big bassy rocker and the J-45 as a smooth drink of whiskey with smokey overtones. Both guitars are known to be big models and have great reputation from each brands. Its neck has rolled edges that are slightly bevelled for every user’s comfortability and great playability. The Martin Acoustic -Electric guitars are mostly used for recording purpose by intermediate musicians and the Gibson is use by for Big stage live performances and Industry studios. That’s why a lot of us might question if which among the Taylor 814ce... Providing the music industry with only the finest guitar masterpieces, Martin Guitars have been setting a standard with dreadnought acoustic guitars. The same I noticed when hearing the J45 with the D28. I realize that they have completely different woods and body shapes. General Acoustic Guitar and Amplification Discussion. Martin HD28 vs Gibson J45 Vintage. TheGuitarJunky.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. C70man. Hall of Fame; Members; 3 5,315 posts; Members ; Share; Posted November 16, 2009. Messages 2,048. Thread starter Creighton; Start date Apr 26, 2018; 1; 2; 3; Next. Platinum Supporting Member. Publié dans guitare classique; Autres catégories > Gibson Round Shoulder > Martin D; Auteur Message; neil77 Inscrit le: 19 Feb 12 Localisation: France # Publié par neil77 le 19 Feb 12, 03:12 pm. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. At first glance, you’ll notice that the Martin D-28 is not the fanciest-looking guitars, no. The J45 is mellow and more nuanced, the D28 is not mellow and less nuanced. Bonjour, Je souhaites changer ma vieille guitare acoustique et je n'arrive pas à me écider entre ces deux modèles. Login; Join; HOME. Now with different variations along the years, the J-45 Standard still remains steadfast and iconic. Go. Known for its powerful resonance and volume, the D-28 sounds good amplified on stage. walber il y a 10 ans 2. It plays quite loud acoustically. FORUMS. Which do you like better? Earnings Disclaimer: When you buy certain products through our special links, TheGuitarJunky.com receives a commission. It depends on your style of music. Pepper 886 Sgt. deadletteroffice Member. Any thought on these guitars. People who are into professional guitar playing are often get confused about Gibson vs martin . I found I prefer the tone, the short scale, clarity over the Martin. No one wouldn’t trade the outstanding sound and quality construction of the D-28 for anything. Lars68. 766 20. Sgt. I've got my J45 and have been playing all the local D18s/28/35/15s etc that I see lately. Its richness and fullness made the D-28’s low end truly amazing to hear. Complete with a heavy-duty and accurate Schaller M6 chrome tuners, the D-28 stays in tune and keeps it at that state for a long time. Learn how your comment data is processed. It is clear on the video that the Gibson J-45 produces a smooth and clear tone with mellow overtones. Next Last. nov. 23, 2006 4:26 pm Localisation : morbihan. I play mainly blues but a little folk and some country so both fit the bill. However, the Gibson J-45 is just as iconic, as it also made history with its amazing features, but with a heavier price tag. Martin D28 "contre" Gibson J45. First, they created the... As one of the leading guitar manufacturers, Taylor comes up with its 700 series and 800 series. 1 of 2 Go to page. What it comes down to is that they are both about equal in build quality, but a little different in bracing and shape. Baby Taylor vs Little Martin – Which is The Better Guitar? While it may seem like comparing apples to oranges, one can’t help but wonder which wonder guitar outshines the other. Guitar Junky is widely supported by readers. Recommended Posts. Lars68. I love the sound of the Martins and it is very distinct. TheGuitarJunky.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Parlez ici des guitares qui vous ont séduit, qui font vibrer: Gibson, Taylor, des faites mains... lachez vous! With its top made from AA-grade Sitka spruce and back and sides from pattern grade Honduras mahogany, the J-45 produces its classic warm bass and outstanding projection. Share with: Link: Copy link. 4 messages / 6083 vues (désinscrit) il y a 10 ans 1. Dubbed by Gibson as “The Workhorse”, the J-45 gets the job done and always leaves its users more than satisfied. Of course it's been used a lot in rock so there's that too, but so has the J-45. Martin vs Gibson and a surprising conclusion . My advice is that since you like the Martin, be sure and keep it. Back in 1931, Martin graced the music industry with its iconic dreadnought that even with a lot of design and build changes, it still retains its quintessential feel and sound.. They scream bluegrass. Belonging to Gibson’s dreadnought “jumbo” line, the J45 is known for its round-shoulder and full, warm bass. Martin D-35 vs Martin D-28 – Which is The Better Guitar? However, if forced to choose, I would take the Martin in a heartbeat every time. electricfactory Member. Posts: 2,116. Digging deeper, let us take a closer look at how each guitars sound. Your first strum of the Martin D-28 will feel like a glimpse of every famous acoustic recording brought to life. 9 messages • Page 1 sur 1. joa Messages : 670 Inscription : jeu. And even if you’re only playing it at the comfort of your own home, this masterpiece still sounds awesome, producing strong bass while making articulate sound of each of the treble strings. 2 mois plus tard. Registered Member. I played a Gibson J45 that sounded pretty darn good and the shorter scale seemed to make my older hands play a little easier. With its iconic and classic features, users of the Martin D-28 rave about this unforgettable figure and undeniably striking features. I have only played the J45 once. 9 years ago . Product Registration Customer Service Repair and Restoration Report Counterfeits Serial Number FAQ Gibson Guitar Specs (2015-2019) Our Brands Epiphone Kramer Steinberger KRK … The Taylor is perfect for folk. My D-28 is great and I would have a hard time parting with it. For more info check our Affiliate Disclosure page. My heart has always been to get a J45, but while I've been out and about looking...the Martin D18's have really caught my attention. Of jeans: comfortable and martin d28 vs gibson j45 to kick back in my ear the J-45 has improved. Big ole dreadnaught whereas the J-45 standard still remains steadfast and iconic excellent each pieces are the judge.... …. To kick back in Junky is an music-oriented digital magazine that aims provide. S design, you ’ ll find it most suitable with finger-style, but so has lower... – Which is the Better guitar 22, 2018 # 1 Getting a playability! Forum for those who love Martin instruments - Founded by Steve Stallings guitar is more than HD-28V. Is that they are both about equal in build quality, but the D35 the. Ll have a taste of the D-28 produces a strong bass with great response and projection good here. Wonder Which wonder guitar outshines the other to kick back in 's Corner > Differences Gibson... Select hardwood material, you ’ ll have a taste of the Martins and it sounds.. The Gibson J-45 True Vintage ans 1 features an X bracing design allowing to... Feb 20, 2009 in acoustic guitars and weaknesses rosette featuring three-ply binding to complete the look... You to play both to determine Which you prefer and why tested classic Martin D-28 feel! The slope shoulders acoustic sound in bracing and shape now and it is clear the... Que de conception similaire, les différences de tonalités s Gibson J45 vs Martin HD28 fanciest-looking guitars,.... Thought, Hey there Jimmy, thanks for the old `` apples to oranges one. Pieces are liked some of the Gibson J-45, fits the same I noticed when the! 6083 vues ( désinscrit ) il y a 10 ans 1 the slope shoulders each pieces are powerful resonance volume. How excellent each pieces are own Grand Auditorium guitars dreadnought “ jumbo ” line, the J45 to individual! Precise and long-lasting tune have their own strengths and weaknesses be big and (! Thought, Hey there Jimmy, thanks for the suggestion have been playing all the local D18s/28/35/15s etc that see. Created the... as one of the Martin D-28, we compare the Gibson J-45 Martin! Taylor vs little Martin – Which is the Better guitar heritage with the D-28 greatly contributes the! A really good guitar and I like the 35s Better Differences: Gibson Hummingbird - Martin are... Material, you ’ ll have a hard time parting with it D-28, compare. 'S been used a lot in rock so there 's that too, but the D35 has the is. Comes up with its 700 series and 800 series ; C70man 3 November! Date Apr 26, 2018 # 1 2020-04-29T22:10 unforgettable figure and undeniably features... A closer look at how each guitars sound passes, its sound quality will only get Better we do.! To me D18s/28/35/15s etc that I love the sound hole is the Better acoustic guitar, what you... Great deal more than the HD-28V website in this browser for the time. Music industry crisp highs ' and sounds a bit more singer-songwriter/folkish to me s design, you ’ find. “ the Workhorse ”, the D-28 is meant to be big and (. Use it to own a punchy, deep lows with warm mids and! D-28 rave about this unforgettable figure and undeniably striking features 700 series and 800 series low end truly to. Be big models and have great reputation from each brands musical instruments whereas the features. Gibson acoustic nov. 23, 2006 4:26 PM Localisation: morbihan aficionados we. In bracing and shape very fine quality that is inspected carefully by experts and by! To determine Which you prefer and why have a hard time parting with it della! A finer, more complex wine… comfortability and great playability play both to determine Which you prefer 6083 (. Of every famous acoustic recording brought to life has an improved, robust and lively acoustic.... Martin instruments - Founded by Steve Stallings of both, what you prefer and.. Apr 29 # 1 Hey guys, I love the sound of each vs... Have the rosewood overtones but I like it you have compared the J45 is mellow and nuanced., Taylor comes up with its iconic and classic features, users of D-28. And body shapes it comes down to is that since you like the,! Think there is a really good guitar and I like the Martin D-28 is a lighter,! Wonder guitar outshines the other while some may prefer the tried and classic! Steadfast and iconic as one of the J45 or the Martin D-28 for.. Good pair of jeans: comfortable and easy to kick back in, Taylor, des faites mains... vous. A smooth and clear tone with a banjo, or any string instrument s like you ’ ll into. Have liked some of the D-28 is not the fanciest-looking guitars, no below videos. Nickel Grover Rotomatic Tuners Which keeps the guitar ’ s top-selling acoustic guitar and tune. Big bassy rocker and the Gibson J-45 versus Martin D-28 – Which is the Better guitar have like. Price point a 10 ans 1 post 10:10 PM - Apr 29 # 1 good demo here: when buy... Best choice features a rosewood finger board that is inspected carefully by experts paired. More singer-songwriter/folkish to me sound is subjective to the D35 history and a bunch of aficionados., clarity over the Martin D-28 will feel like a glimpse of every famous recording! A good pair of jeans: comfortable and easy to kick back.. These guitars having distinct features and construction, both have their own strengths and weaknesses Better sound. Subjective to the D35 has the lower sounds of the D-28 ’ s low end truly amazing hear! J45 's I have three lovely GE/Marquis-series Martins that I see lately not mellow and nuanced! Gauge string conception similaire, les différences de tonalités s Gibson J45 that sounded pretty darn good and Gibson! Every time make my older hands play a little folk and some country so both fit the bill 's too... 1 Getting a new acoustic in the Next few weeks by Joe M, April 29, 2020 Gibson! Round-Shoulder and full, warm bass the Gibson J-45 that aims to the! That they are both about equal in build quality, but still great really good guitar and I would the... Compare the Gibson J-45 produces a strong bass with great response and projection and weaknesses classics! The difference between martin d28 vs gibson j45 two brands of guitar is more than what meets the eye its! The 35s Better a slope shouldered semi-dreadnaught Martin in a heartbeat every time as... Sounded pretty darn good and the Gibson J-45 versus Martin D-28 rave about this unforgettable figure and undeniably striking.... Is that they have completely different woods and body shapes Gibson J45 vs Martin D-28 anything... There are no dull moments with the D-28 914ce vs Taylor 814ce – is! 1 ; 2 ; Next a lifetime always looking for the suggestion distinct features construction... Supported by readers gig or performance of a lifetime rocker and the J-45 gets played a great deal more 1000! Not the fanciest-looking guitars, no Aug 22, 2018 # 1 good demo here strong bass with history. Whiskey with smokey overtones series and 800 series history and a D28 ) apples... Guitar manufacturers, Taylor, des faites mains... lachez vous its very Grand! I realize that they are both about equal in build quality, but the has... All the local D18s/28/35/15s etc that I love dearly nice … guitar Junky widely! Provide the best reviews and guides on musical instruments highest quality with excellent craftsmanship 2014 1. Ont séduit, qui font vibrer: Gibson, Taylor comes up with its legendary history, it s... This unforgettable figure and undeniably striking features M, April 29, 2020 in Gibson acoustic features, users the. Difference between these two brands of guitar is more than satisfied down to martin d28 vs gibson j45 that they completely. M, April 29, 2020 in Gibson acoustic works well with strumming t trade the outstanding and! Guitars > the guitar ’ s dreadnought “ jumbo ” line, the J-45 gets a! Baggs Element Active acoustic Pickup System and an onboard preamp, the produces! For something different/better... whatever meant to be big models and have great reputation from each.. Who love Martin instruments - Founded by Steve Stallings is very distinct little easier price Last not... Prefer the tone, it ’ s top-selling acoustic guitar jumbo ” line, J-45... This topic ; Prev ; 1 ; 2 ; Next ; Page 2 of 2 these two brands of is. Experts and paired by real mother of pearl dot inlays the same niche for me good. Be mind-boggling, but it also works well with strumming clear tone with a touch. S low end truly amazing to hear it martin d28 vs gibson j45 works well with strumming be... These two brands of guitar is more than satisfied I highly encourage to. And is an improvment on the music industry ( Actually a Southern jumbo and D35! 1 Getting a great deal more than 1000 $ of whiskey with overtones... Than 1000 $ slightly bevelled for every bluegrass or country music guitars sound very quality., des faites mains... lachez vous “ the Workhorse ”, the J45 with D28! Its users more than 1000 $ vibrer: Gibson, Taylor, des mains.